On March 31, 2026, Coinbase shut down Coinbase Commerce for every merchant outside the US and Singapore. No extensions. If you built a checkout around Commerce and don't operate from one of those two countries, you're already shopping for a new provider.
At the same time, MiCA stopped being optional. The EU's transitional period for crypto-asset service providers closed EU-wide on July 1, 2026. Any provider still serving EU clients without a MiCA licence is now operating in breach of EU law, per ++ESMA's own statement++. Licensing went from a nice-to-have to the first filter.
So here's a ranked comparison, built on stated criteria.
How we ranked these
- Regulatory licensing. Does the provider hold a real license (MiCA, money transmitter, or equivalent), or none? Getting a standalone money-transmitter license across US states alone can cost $1 million to $10 million, which is why most merchants route through an already-licensed provider rather than pursuing this independently.
- Fee structure. Flat, tiered, or volume-based, and whether the headline number is the whole story.
- Settlement. What currency you get paid in, how fast the fiat lands, and how fast the on-chain payment itself confirms.
- Custody model. Does the provider hold your funds before you withdraw, or do you keep control the whole time?
- Integrations. Plugins and platforms it actually connects to.
At a glance
| Provider | Licensing | Fee | Settlement | Custody | Best for |
| CoinGate | MiCA + PI licensed (Lithuania) | 1% flat | EUR/USD/GBP via SEPA, next business day | Custodial | EU e-commerce needing regulatory clarity |
| BitPay | US-regulated, KYC/AML | 2%+$0.25 under $500K/mo, down to 1%+$0.25 above $1M/mo | Multi-currency fiat or crypto | Custodial | Established, high-volume merchants |
| NOWPayments | Lighter/no formal licensing disclosed | 0.5%–1% | Fiat or crypto | Custodial | Lowest headline fee, broadest coin list |
| Coinbase (via Business or Shopify) | US/Singapore for Business; 34 countries via Shopify's native USDC | 1% for Commerce migrants | USDC-focused | Custodial | Depends which path applies to you: see note below |
| Plisio | Non-custodial, lighter regulatory footprint | 0.5% flat | Crypto to your own wallet | Non-custodial | Merchants who don't want a third party holding funds |
| BTCPay Server | None — self-hosted, no formal licensing | 0% (network fee only) | Direct to your wallet | Non-custodial | Technical merchants who want zero platform fees and full control |
1. CoinGate: best for EU-regulated merchants
CoinGate has run since 2014 out of Lithuania and became the first Lithuanian company to hold a MiCA license, alongside a separate Payment Institution license. That combination gives it a passport across all 27 EU member states under one framework, which matters now that the transitional grace period is closed.
The fee is a flat 1%, no monthly charge. It settles into EUR, USD, or GBP via SEPA the next business day, and supports 70-plus cryptocurrencies. Plugin coverage runs to WooCommerce, Magento, PrestaShop, and OpenCart, the widest of any provider on this list for standard e-commerce platforms.
The catch: full merchant KYC/KYB is mandatory, so onboarding takes longer than some competitors.
2. BitPay: best for high-volume, established merchants
BitPay has run since 2011, longer than any other name here, and its pricing reflects an enterprise-first model: 2% + $0.25 under $500K in monthly volume, dropping to 1.5% + $0.25 from $500K, and 1% + $0.25 once you clear $1 million a month.
It's custodial and integrates with QuickBooks for accounting. Invoice exchange rates lock for 15 minutes, protecting both sides from price swings during payment.
Coin coverage is broad; sources differ on the exact count (100+ core assets, more if network variants are counted separately), so confirm your specific assets are supported before committing.
The catch: at low volume, the fee is the highest on this list. Skip this one if you're a small merchant just starting out.
3. NOWPayments: best for lowest fees and asset coverage
NOWPayments charges 0.5% to 1%, the lowest headline rate here, and independently reported as supporting the widest range of cryptocurrencies of any major gateway, over 350 by some counts.
The regulatory picture is lighter than CoinGate or BitPay. Worth checking directly with them what licensing applies in your jurisdiction before you commit, especially post-MiCA.
4. Coinbase: two separate paths
This one needs unpacking, because there are genuinely two separate products here.
Coinbase Business is the direct successor to Commerce. It's custodial and USDC-focused, a different model from the any-asset, self-custodial setup Commerce offered. It's currently available only to businesses with a legal entity in the US or Singapore, with more countries expected through 2026 but no confirmed dates.
If you're outside those two countries and already run on Shopify, there's a separate path. Shopify's native USDC checkout, built with Coinbase's Base network and Stripe, is live in 34 countries including much of Europe. No separate gateway integration needed if you're already on Shopify Payments. It's USDC-only and Base-only. It's also real and available right now, which the Commerce shutdown notice alone doesn't make obvious.
5. Plisio: best if you don't want a custodian
Plisio charges a flat 0.5% and never takes custody of your funds. Payments go straight to your own wallet. For a merchant uncomfortable with a third party holding crypto even briefly, that's the clearest differentiator on this list.
The trade-off is a smaller compliance and support footprint than CoinGate or BitPay, so weigh that against your own risk tolerance and jurisdiction.
6. BTCPay Server: best for zero fees and full sovereignty
BTCPay Server is free and open-source. It's also self-hosted: you run it on your own server or a third-party host, and it charges nothing beyond the Bitcoin network fee, typically a dollar or two per transaction, paid directly to miners.
It's non-custodial and requires no KYC. Its invoice API is compatible with BitPay's, so migrating away from BitPay is a known, documented path.
The trade-off is real: no built-in fiat conversion, and you're responsible for hosting and keeping it updated. This is the pick for a technically capable merchant who wants full control and zero platform fees. A business that wants a vendor to just handle it should look elsewhere on this list.
What none of these solve
Every provider above assumes a merchant plugging a gateway into a single checkout. A business that needs crypto acceptance and fiat banking under one roof, with no ceiling on monthly volume and a desk that can handle a large trade manually, needs something built differently.
That's a different category of buyer: a fintech platform or an enterprise merchant processing well beyond typical self-serve limits, who needs the payment side and the banking side handled as a single relationship.
Which one fits your business
| Your situation | Best fit |
| EU e-commerce, need MiCA-compliant fiat settlement | CoinGate |
| Established, high monthly volume, want accounting integration | BitPay |
| Want the lowest fee and broadest coin list | NOWPayments |
| US or Singapore, already on Coinbase | Coinbase Business |
| On Shopify, outside US/Singapore, want native USDC | Shopify's built-in USDC checkout |
| Don't want a custodian holding your funds | Plisio |
| Technical team, want zero platform fees | BTCPay Server |
| Enterprise B2B, need banking + crypto + no volume ceiling | Different category: see pay-by-crypto |
Related reading: Pay-by-Crypto for B2B · How to choose a crypto payment gateway · What is a crypto payment gateway?
